Latest insights
California’s Song-Beverly Warranty Act and Solar Panels: A Legal Theory Worth Knowing, With Real Limits

California’s Song-Beverly Warranty Act and Solar Panels: A Legal Theory Worth Knowing, With Real Limits

Most solar warranty disputes in California get framed around two documents: the manufacturer’s written warranty and the installer’s workmanship warranty.
There’s a third thing sitting underneath both of them that almost never comes up: California’s Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, the same law behind the state’s “lemon law” for cars. It creates an implied warranty that exists by operation of law, separate from anything written in your contract. It’s also narrower, and more legally uncertain as applied to solar, than some online summaries suggest.
What the implied warranty actually says
Under Civil Code §1791.1, every retail sale of consumer goods in California is automatically accompanied by an implied warranty of merchantability, meaning the goods are fit for their ordinary purpose, regardless of what’s written in any separate warranty document. Critically, this implied warranty cannot be waived or disclaimed by the seller for goods sold with a written warranty, something a manufacturer’s own warranty terms can’t override.
The duration limit that matters
Here’s where the theory gets narrower than it first sounds. The implied warranty’s duration under §1791.1 runs concurrently with any express written warranty, but by statute it can be no shorter than 60 days and no longer than one year after the goods are delivered. It is not a 25-year warranty riding alongside your panel manufacturer’s 25-year warranty. It’s a short window, and it closes well before most solar equipment problems show up.
What Mexia v. Rinker Boat Co. actually changed
A 2009 California Court of Appeal decision, Mexia v. Rinker Boat Co., is often cited as extending this protection. What it actually held is narrower than “you can sue anytime”: a latent defect, one that existed but wasn’t discoverable, breaches the implied warranty at the moment the defect exists, even if nobody finds out about it until later. The lawsuit itself still has to be filed within the four-year statute of limitations that courts have applied to these claims (borrowed from the Uniform Commercial Code), and that clock has generally been tied to the date of delivery or sale, not the date you discovered the problem. Later courts, including a 2024 appellate decision, have continued to wrestle with exactly how this plays out, and outcomes have gone against plaintiffs when they couldn’t show the defect existed during that narrow 60-day-to-one-year window.
In plain terms: if a defect was present in your system from day one but didn’t show symptoms until year six, this theory might still apply. If a part failed in year six because of ordinary wear, it almost certainly doesn’t.
Two real limits nobody should gloss over
It likely doesn’t cover leases or PPAs. Song-Beverly’s implied warranty attaches to a retail sale of consumer goods. If you lease your system or have a PPA, you never purchased the equipment, the solar company still owns it. Whether this implied warranty theory has any application to you at all is a real legal question, and based on what I can find, the stronger argument applies to homeowners who purchased their system outright or financed it as a purchase.
Whether an installed solar system even counts as “consumer goods” under the Act is genuinely unsettled, at least as far as I can find. Courts have gone both ways on whether specific products qualify as “consumer goods” versus something else, like a fixture permanently affixed to real property, which can fall under different legal frameworks entirely (like California’s construction defect statutes). I found no published California case applying Song-Beverly specifically to a residential solar installation. That doesn’t mean the argument fails. It means it’s untested, and any attorney raising it would be making a novel application of existing law, not citing a case that’s already decided this exact question.
Why this is still worth knowing
Even with those limits, this is a legal theory worth having in your back pocket, for a specific, narrower situation than “my panels broke”:
- You own your system (purchased outright or via a loan), not leasing or PPA.
- The problem can plausibly be traced to a defect that existed from installation, not ordinary wear years later.
- Your manufacturer’s written warranty has a gap, exclusion, or dispute that leaves you without another clear path.
In that narrow situation, this is worth raising with an attorney, not as a guaranteed win, but as an additional angle alongside your manufacturer warranty claim and any claim against your installer.
What to document if you think this might apply
- The exact delivery or installation date, which starts the duration clock.
- Any evidence the defect existed from the start, like inspection notes, early service calls, or photos from installation.
- Your manufacturer’s written warranty terms, including its own start date and duration.
- Whether you purchased or financed the system, versus leasing it or having a PPA, since this changes whether the theory applies at all.
Our documentation checklist covers the broader approach, and our guide to proving a solar production shortfall covers a related, more commonly used path.
Questions about Song-Beverly and solar panels
Does this apply if I lease my solar system?
Likely not. The implied warranty attaches to a retail sale of consumer goods, and a lease or PPA customer doesn’t purchase the equipment. This theory applies more clearly, if at all, to homeowners who own their system outright.
Does this mean my implied warranty lasts as long as my manufacturer’s 25-year warranty?
No. The implied warranty’s own duration is capped by statute at no more than one year after delivery, regardless of how long any separate written warranty runs. What Mexia addresses is whether a defect that existed during that window can still be the basis of a lawsuit filed later, within the broader statute of limitations.
Has a California court specifically ruled that solar panels are covered by Song-Beverly?
Not that I could find. This is a legal theory extending existing law to a new context, not a settled question. An attorney would need to make this argument, not simply cite a case that already decided it for solar.
Think a defect in your purchased solar system may have existed from day one, even if it only showed up later?
Send us your documentation and we’ll help you think through every avenue available, including this one, usually in about 15 minutes.
Call (213) 579-5156 or visit californiasolarexit.com.
By Daniel Merritt, Senior Solar Contract Analyst
Daniel Merritt is a Senior Solar Contract Analyst at California Solar Exit. This article is general information, not legal advice. The legal theory discussed here is not a settled or guaranteed path, and results depend entirely on the facts of each case and the advice of a qualified attorney.
Other insights




